Friday 28 December 2007

Racism?

Whilst perusing the top news stories from 2007 this afternoon, I reread the story about the Educate Together school in Balbriggan. The majority of pupils in the Junior Infants class were of an African background. There were very few white faces to be seen.

I've read bits and pieces about how Africans were treated in America, how Aborigines were mistreated in Australia and I've always abhorred it. I've admired from afar the Rosa Parks', the Nelson Mandela's, the Martin Luther King's of this world, and the unknown names and faces who have had to put up with all sorts of crap from white people for so long and have found ways and means of overcoming those struggles.

And now I look at myself in the mirror and wonder, am I racist? I pose this question because I have a two year old daughter and I have her on the list for the local Catholic school since birth. Not because I am a particularly religious person at this moment in my life, but because I feel there will be less African children and other children of foreign nationalities. And that is not for any blatant racist reasons rather that it has been suggested that children of immigrants in general don't have English as a first language, and as a second language, it ain't great either. There is also a local Educate Together school and I don't have her name on that one. Before I had any children I admired the ideologies behind the school but now that I am considering education prospects for my first-born, I am a little more selfish in my views.

I worry that too much time would be spent teaching these children English thus holding up the rest of the class. In reality I know that kids pick up languages pretty quickly but still it is a concern. So am I even more of a bigot? Not your normal racist, just a sneaky one, who hides their racism from the world at large. I don't know. I don't know what the solution is to best include immigrants into our society. Generally inclusion, not exclusion is the key to success in these matters. These kids are entitled to an education just the same as my kid is. They don't deserve to be ghetto-ised at such a young age. Perhaps English lessons for all immigrants should be compulsory. It sounds a bit nanny-state-like though. I have no answers. All I know is that I need to look at myself a little closer.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hi there, I felt compelled to comment on your post as it's a topic that's very close to my heart. I think we are presented with a different side of ourselves when we become parents. We begin to act on fear a lot more which comes from wanting to protect our children.

I'm involved in trying to get an Educate Together school for my town (I'm a mother of a three year old girl) and we have come across this question quite a bit...will our children fall behind because of the foreign children not speaking English as a first language. In talking to parents of children already in schools where other languages and cultures are mixed together the opposite is the case. Children are wide open and the more variety there is the more they will absorb. Rather than being behind, parents are finding that their children...in junior and senior infants...are able to speak in the languages of their peers: Russian, Polish, French.

I really think this fear that's been planted in us about our children suffering from being held back by foreign children needs to be fought tooth and nail. It's like a nasty little voice that whispers in our ears and tells us our children will be damaged in some way, playing on our fears.

Sorry for getting on my soapbox...I guess I feel pretty passionate about this! :D

Jen said...

Hey Claire,

Thanks for leaving your thoughts. I tend to agree with you that kids pick up languages pretty quickly. I just wish there were more statistics available, generally speaking, for primary schools. I guess that's hard to formulate as what way can you tabulate kids that young and besides that, should you? I'm not really in favour of that league table malarkey for youngsters! I guess if you help them at home as well, they should reach their potential or at least have a good shot at it.

Anyways stay on your soapbox, fight for what you believe in and get that school for your daughter!

Marie said...

Damn my messy flat, I could really go to town in this post but I'll save it for our next dinner "date".

Suffice to say I'm with Richard Dawkins all the way on the subject of faith schools...

Marie said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Marie said...

I posted a link but it didn't show up, I'll try again
http://www.simonyi.ox.ac.uk/dawkins/WorldOfDawkins-archive/Dawkins/Work/Articles/2001-12-30morris_letter.shtml does that work?